I remember when she told me. I was sitting at my
desk on a humid August afternoon, sifting through
the avalanche of paperwork that accompanies a real
estate closing. I took her call, grateful for the
break, chirped “Hi” and waited for the bright,
familiar voice. She said, after a round of polite
how are yous, “My doctor thinks I may have cancer.”
Beth and I have been best friends for six years.
I met her at Wesleyan one autumn; she was the first
person I encountered at the admissions office, where
I demurely inquired about transferring. After
spending two years at an Ivy League school
entrenched in pre-professionalism, I had decided
that the remaining undergraduate years would be
better spent learning about myself, not analyzing
supply-and-demand curves. As the receptionist in the
admissions office, Beth had a warm, broad smile. She
spoke swiftly, melodically, making me miserable and
longing to escape a university I felt was swallowing
me – feel at ease at once. We talked about Penn,
men, English literature; she invited me to stay with
her that weekend; I transferred four months later.
We spent the next two years of our lives
together: Saturday night dinners alone, poking fun
at the college social scene; coffee at Howard
Johnson’s at 2 a.m., discussing how we deceive
ourselves and others; smoking our first cigarettes
in her narrow dorm room (neither one of us had been
a rebellious adolescent); discovering feminism.
Through those years, we remained each other’s
closest confidante, the person who knew when we lost
our virginity and to whom; how we wanted to change
the world with our novels (mine) or clinical
practice (hers); what frightened and infuriated us.
For Beth, who had dozens of friends, I was the first
person with whom she could really be herself. For
me, more insular, more cautious, she was the first
person I believed accepted me unequivocally, without
judgment. Even after we graduated, we stayed in
constant contact, making frequent phone calls to
each other to recount the details of our days.
I remember making the trek to Beth’s home the day
she told me that she, indeed, had lymphoma. Her
parents’ sprawling, four-story house – musty and
cluttered with antiques collected from around the
world – felt more oppressive than usual when I
entered. Upstairs, lying on her parents’ bed, Beth
was surrounded by bouquets of flowers – slim yellow
roses, lush white mums – situated haphazardly around
the dark room. We sat together for hours, I
patiently listening while she took phone call after
phone call from friends wishing her well. I had a
sense then that she was about to embark on a journey
without me, to undertake something I could not help
her with, but neither one of us said so that day. I
don’t even know if she sensed the same thing; she
was more fearful, I think, of the grim future that
now was before her.
Beth spent the following year shuttling into
Manhattan every Friday, alternating between
radiation therapy and chemotherapy. We still were in
touch, but rather than call her every day, I would
phone a few days after her treatments, always aware
on those intervening days that she was scared,
alone. Those days she spent in agony –vomiting, her
entire body aching – were as unfathomable to me as
the size of the universe, as untouchable as the
farthest star. I couldn’t imagine what those days
were like for her, those hours of wondering whether
she would ever celebrate her 25th birthday, bear
children, see her sisters grow old. She spoke about
those days only afterwards: She slept a lot, read
a lot, thought a lot.
Today, two years later, with Beth 95 percent
certain that her cancer won’t return, there are
things she has been through that I will never know.
She lived at the threshold of her own death for a
year, and I can only wonder what that was like. And,
for all our wanting to intertwine our lives, for all
our shared moments of laughter and anguish, she
survived this ordeal – those moments flung up
against her own mortality – with only herself to
sustain her.
We still are close, still see each other every
week for coffee, trying to unravel the meaning of
our lives, lives growing more complicated as the
years pass. Yet sometimes when I look at her, I
remember the journeys through tunnels of darkness
that each of us must make: alone, afraid, with only
ourselves as our guides.
Subscribe to our weekly e-newsletter