ARTICLES / General /Validation Therapy /
Other Articles
By Naomi Feil, M.S., A.C.S.W.
(Page 1 of 2)
In the Alzheimer’s wing of the nursing home,
93-year-old Ellie Turner stuffs more napkins into her
worn-out black purse. The tarnished gold clasp clicks
into place for the one hundredth time in one hour. “I
have to fix the Underwood,” she says as she moves toward
the bathroom to change her pants.
Mrs. Turner is called Alzheimer’s demented, but I have
found that her behavior—and the behavior of thousands
like her—makes sense. Her behavior is caused not only by
damage to her recent memory, her logical thinking, and
her inability to tell clock time, but also by the way
she has lived her life. If someone enters her world,
accepting or validating her needs, she will not become
one of the living dead. She will die with dignity and
self-respect.
As a bookkeeper and file clerk for a large electric
company, Mrs. Turner used an Underwood typewriter for 50
years. When she was retired against her will at the age
of sixty-five, she put her trusty office companion in
her dining room. Every morning, Mrs. Turner’s daughter
found her typing for her “company.” Mrs. Turner knew she
was retired, but she could not accept the reality of her
situation. Her work was the most important thing in her
life, and she could not give it up. When, at age 93, she
could not accept the fact that she was losing bladder
control, she associated the loss of her Underwood with
the loss of control. She went to the bathroom to fix her
machine. The Underwood became a symbol of her old-age
losses.
Very old people who have not prepared for the physical
and psychological blows of aging often use symbols to
express their needs. They have not learned to face pain,
anger, frustration, shame, or guilt. Throughout life,
they have denied painful emotions. In very old age, the
denial worsens, and they blame others for their own
failures. Each age has its own, unique tendencies. A
three-year-old who talks to an imaginary playmate is not
hallucinating; she is developing her imagination and
verbal skills. If, at age 13, she talked to an imaginary
playmate, we would worry. By the same token, an
85-year-old is very different—physically, socially, and
psychologically—from a 70-year-old. We lose thousands of
brain cells each year, beginning in our late twenties.
Not surprising, this loss of brain tissue can affect our
logical thinking areas after eight to 10 decades of wear
and tear.
Printable Version