ARTICLES / General /Driving Dilemmas: Risk vs. Independence /
Other Articles
Driving Dilemmas: Risk vs. Independence
By Kristine Dwyer, Staff Writer
Driving a car is a symbol of independence and
competence and is closely tied to an individual’s
identity. It also represents freedom and control and
allows older adults to gain easy access to social
connections, health care, shopping, activities and even
employment. At some point, however, it is predictable
that driving skills will deteriorate and individuals
will lose the ability to safely operate a vehicle. Even
though age alone does not determine when a person needs
to stop driving, the decision must be balanced with
personal and public safety. Driving beyond one’s ability
brings an increased safety risk or even life-threatening
situations to all members of society. Statistics show
that older drivers are more likely than others to
receive traffic citations for failing to yield, making
improper left turns, and running red lights or stop
signs, which are all indications of a decrease in
driving skills. Understandably, dealing with impaired
older drivers is a delicate issue.
The road to driving cessation is anything but smooth.
Each year, hundreds of thousands of older drivers across
the country must face the end of their driving years and
become transportation dependent. Unfortunately, finding
other means of transportation has not noticeably
improved in recent years, leading to a reluctance among
older drivers to give up driving privileges and of
families to remove the car keys. The primary issue
facing older drivers is how to adapt to changes in
driving performance while maintaining necessary
mobility. Despite being a complicated issue, this
process can be more successful when there is a
partnership between the physician, older driver, family
or caregiver.
Dramatic headlines like these have ignited national
media debates and triggered the pressing need for more
testing and evaluation of elderly drivers, especially
with the swell of the Baby Boomer generation: “Family of four killed by an 80-year-old man driving the
wrong way on Highway 169. 86-year-old driver
killed 10 people when his vehicle plowed through a
farmers’ market in southern California. 93-year-old man
crashed his car into a Wal-Mart store, sending six
people to the hospital and injuring a 1-year-old child.”
According to the Hartford Insurance Corporation,
statistics of older drivers show that after age 75,
there is a higher risk of being involved in a collision
for every mile driven. The rate of risk is nearly equal
to the risk of younger drivers ages 16 to 24. The rate
of fatalities increases slightly after age 65 and
significantly after age 75. Although older persons with
health issues can be satisfactory drivers, they have a
higher likelihood of injury or death in an accident.
Undoubtedly, an older adult’s sense of independence vs.
driving risk equals a very sensitive and emotionally
charged topic. Older adults may agree with the decline
of their driving ability, yet feel a sense of loss,
blame others, attempt to minimize and justify, and
ultimately may feel depressed at the thought of giving
up driving privileges. Driving is an earned privilege
and in order to continue to drive safely, guidelines and
regulations must be in place to evaluate and support
older drivers.
Printable Version